Meet the MVP Team

Welcome to MVP Insurance, where securing your future is our MVP move. Led by insurance professionals Joshua Medure and David Varrati, our agency is dedicated to providing comprehensive coverage for clients from all walks of life.


At MVP Insurance, we understand that life's uncertainties can affect anyone. Whether you're a small business owner, a homeowner, or someone looking for reliable insurance, we're here to protect you.Our commitment to winning solutions and tailored coverage is unwavering. Just as a sports MVP excels in their game, we excel in delivering peace of mind through our insurance offerings.


Choose MVP Insurance for dependable coverage that adapts to your unique needs and life's unpredictable twists. We're here to safeguard your present and future, ensuring you have the protection you deserve. Join the MVP family today, where every client is valued as the most valuable person in their own life's game.

Screen Shot 2023-03-03 at 10.04.21 AM

David Varrati

Screen Shot 2023-03-03 at 10.04.38 AM

Josh Medure

Marcie Presto

Marcie Presto

Office Manager
Screen Shot 2023-03-03 at 10.26.12 AM

Terry Dobson

Commercial Sales Agent
Michelle Plaufcan

Michelle Plaufcan

Personal Lines Account Manager
Marcie Wirtjes

Marcie Wirtjes

Personal Lines Account Manager
Brandy Photo

Brandy Young


Edi Reinhart

Commercial Account Manager

Bethany Sauers

Account Manager

“We know that the process of buying a home can be an exciting and chaotic process. We focus on being able to help you simplify the experience.”

David and Josh both worked for Liberty Mutual in Pittsburgh before going independent.

“We have been buddies from an early age,” David admits. “Fourteen years ago, we decided that we wanted to start our own business in Northeast Ohio. We started a scratch agency that began with no clients and grew from there.” Early on, David and Josh moved from insurance generalists to specialists in the new home purchase portion of the mar - ket. This strategy has helped them to successfully grow their business organically and through acquisition. MVP’s real estate referral network spans from Northeast Ohio to Western Pennsylvania.“ We are an independent agency,” David says. “That means we have access to multiple companies. That helps us be able to provide a range of different options for our referral partners and their clients when it comes to their insurance.” Josh and David still maintain an office in Northeast Ohio and recently pur - chased an office in Zelienople, PA. The two are also quick to shine the spotlight on their team, which includes Marcie Presto, Brandy Young, Michelle Plaufcan, Edie Matthews, Terry Dobson and Marcie Wirtjes. “We all honor our commitment to put - ting valuable protection in place for those we serve. Our clients can go to bed knowing they are fully protected. We want them to have a good client expe - rience,” Josh says. “Although we are independent, we are honored to say that Erie Insurance is our primary carrier.” David and his wife, Maria, treasure time with their children, Anneliese, Viviana and Antonio. In his free time, David has a passion for coaching his son in sports and watching his girls compete in sports and gymnastics, and he also likes to play basketball and take part in CrossFit classes. Josh and his wife, Dana, are the proud parents of three chil - dren as well, Nico, Dante and Italia. Josh has also enjoyed getting involved with his children’s activities. In fact, he has been a Pop Warner football coach for the past six years. Away from work, he also enjoys golf and exploring local restaurants. When you need a partner to help your clients secure home insurance quickly with value and care, look to David Varrati and Josh Medure of MVP Insurance.

Call Email Claims Payments