Local Pennsylvania Erie Insurance Agents

Owner, MVP Insurance

Looking for local Pennsylvania Erie insurance agents? Most people want two things: a carrier with a strong claims record, and a nearby person who will pick up the phone when something goes wrong. MVP Insurance places Erie auto, home, business and life coverage as an independent agent, and we compare Erie against other carriers at every renewal.


That last part matters more than most people realize. Erie earns loyalty across western Pennsylvania, but no carrier fits every household or business forever. Your situation might change, Erie's pricing might shift, or you could end up with a coverage gap nobody explained when the policy started. This page explains how we place Erie, who it tends to suit, and what we do when a renewal notice arrives looking different from last year's.

Looking for an Erie Agent in Pennsylvania?

People look for an Erie agent because of the company's reputation for fair claims handling and steady pricing. Erie was ranked #1 in the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, and it keeps an NAIC complaint ratio of 0.55, roughly 45% below the industry average for a carrier its size. Those numbers support what many Pennsylvania families already hear from neighbors.


Erie sells through agents, so you'll need one to get a policy. MVP Insurance is an independent agency founded in 2008 by Josh Medure and David Varrati. We work with Erie as one of several carrier partners, alongside Westfield, Progressive and others. To be clear, MVP is not Erie. We're a local agency that is appointed to write Erie policies, and we can also show you what other carriers would offer for the same coverage.

David Varrati

By: Joshua Medure

Owner, MVP Insurance


MVP Insurance is a local, independent agency, licensed to serve individuals and businesses across Ohio and Pennsylvania.

We serve clients from our offices in New Springfield and Zelienople and throughout Northeast Ohio and Western Pennsylvania, working with multiple carriers to help homeowners, drivers, renters and condo owners, landlords, contractors, restaurant owners, shop owners, auto repair shops, professional offices and many other personal and commercial clients find coverage that fits.

Written By

David Varrati

Owner, MVP Insurance


Owner, MVP Insurance

On this page

Why Work with MVP Instead of Going Direct?

Working with an independent agency gives you Erie plus a fallback, all in one conversation. Erie is a top-tier carrier, but if it isn't the right match for your car, your house or your business, we can quote Western Reserve, Liberty Mutual, GEICO and others without making you start over somewhere else.


An agent who represents a single carrier can only tell you what that carrier offers. If the price isn't right or the underwriting rules exclude you, the conversation usually ends there. We act as an advisor first. Our job is to understand what you're protecting, then figure out which carrier handles that risk well. Sometimes that's Erie. Sometimes it's a carrier you've never considered.


You can see the full list of companies we work with on our carriers page.We also use modern tools that make managing policies, ID cards and payments simpler, and our clients have access to 24/7 claims service.

Written By

David Varrati

Owner, MVP Insurance


Owner, MVP Insurance

On this page

Placing Erie Auto, Home, Business and Life Coverage

MVP places four main lines with Erie: auto, home, business and life. Each one has its own features, and the details below describe how these policies typically work. Specific coverages depend on underwriting and the endorsements you choose.


  • Auto:Erie auto policies may include the Erie Rate Lock feature, which generally keeps your premium steady year over year. Under that program, rates typically change only when you add or remove a driver, a vehicle or a primary residence. In Pennsylvania, you'll also choose between limited tort and full tort, a decision that affects your right to sue for pain and suffering after a crash. Our Pennsylvania car insurance pagecovers state requirements in more detail.
  • Home:Erie homeowners policies generally offer broad dwelling and personal property protection, and some forms may include guaranteed replacement cost on the home itself.
  • Business:Erie commercial packages typically bundle property and general liability for small and midsize businesses, with commercial auto and workers' compensation available separately.
  • Life:Erie life coverage generally includes term and permanent options that can pair with your other policies.

Comparing Coverage Options and Limits

The table below shows common choices we review with clients. It's a planning tool, not a quote.

Coverage Area What It Typically Pays For Common Mistake We See
Auto liability Injuries and damage you cause to others Carrying state minimums with a house to protect
PA tort option Limited vs. full right to sue Choosing limited tort without understanding it
Dwelling Rebuilding your home Insuring to market value, not rebuild cost
Water backup Sump pump or drain backup Assuming it's included automatically
Umbrella Liability above auto and home limits Skipping it after buying a teen driver's car
Business liability Customer injuries, property damage Not updating limits as revenue grows

Water backup is the one that catches people most often in older western Pennsylvania homes. A failed sump pump during a spring thaw can ruin a finished basement, and that coverage generally has to be added by endorsement.

Written By

David Varrati

Owner, MVP Insurance


Owner, MVP Insurance

On this page

Who Erie Typically Fits

Erie typically fits people who care more about long-term stability and thorough protection than chasing the lowest rate every year. Think homeowners with a clean claims history, families with multiple vehicles, and small business owners who want one company handling several policies.


The company's financial position supports that kind of relationship. AM Best affirmed an A+ (Excellent) financial strength rating for Erie's property/casualty members, describing its balance sheet as "strongest" even with elevated loss costs across the industry. Erie also rose 15 spots to #308 on the 2026 Fortune 500 list. Erie's management has said it prioritizes pricing discipline over chasing growth, which tends to reward policyholders who stay put.


Erie isn't built for every situation, though. If you own a mobile home, a vacant property or a collector car, specialty carriers are usually a better match. For those needs we place coverage with Foremost, American Modern or Hagerty.

Written By

David Varrati

Owner, MVP Insurance


Owner, MVP Insurance

On this page

How We Compare It at Renewal

At renewal, we look at your Erie policy against the market so you aren't stuck accepting whatever price shows up. That's the core advantage of an independent agency: we have other doors to open if the numbers change.


Here's how that usually plays out. Your Erie renewal arrives, and the homeowners premium jumped because of rising rebuild costs in your area. Before you call us annoyed, we've often already flagged it. We review whether your limits still make sense, check for missed credits like bundling or protective devices, and then quote comparable coverage with partners such as Frederick Mutual, Municipal Mutual or Farmers of McCandless.


Sometimes Erie still comes out ahead once you compare coverage side by side, not just price. Other times a move makes sense. Either way, the goal stays the same: you remain properly protected without doing the shopping yourself. If you ever hit a dispute with a carrier, it helps to know the Pennsylvania Insurance Department recovered $27 million for consumers after investigating more than 16,500 complaints in a single year.

Written By

David Varrati

Owner, MVP Insurance


Owner, MVP Insurance

On this page

Popular Erie Policies and Additional Partners

The Erie policies our clients ask about most are auto and home, often bundled together. Erie generally ranks among the top 11 U.S. providers for auto, home and business insurance by premium volume, so these products have a deep track record.


Popular choices include:


  • Personal auto, often with Rate Lock
  • Homeowners and condo coverage
  • Renters insurance for younger clients
  • Personal umbrella policies
  • Business owners packages for shops, contractors and offices
  • Term life for young families


Not every need fits neatly into an Erie policy, and that's where our other partners come in. J.C. Taylor handles classic and antique vehicles with agreed-value coverage. Franklin Flood covers flood risk, which standard homeowners policies typically exclude, an important point for anyone near the Connoquenessing Creek or other waterways. NEXT can cover certain business needs, especially for contractors and sole proprietors who want fast online access to certificates. For high-risk drivers, Dairyland is another option.

Written By

David Varrati

Owner, MVP Insurance


Owner, MVP Insurance

On this page

How to Get an Erie Quote and Start Coverage

Getting an Erie quote through MVP takes one conversation and a few documents. We do the comparison work, so you aren't filling out the same form five times.


  1. Gather your current policy declarations. These show your existing limits and help us quote accurately.
  2. List drivers, vehicles and property details. VINs, license numbers and your home's roof age and updates make a real difference.
  3. Tell us what matters to you. Price stability, higher liability limits, a specific claims concern. We'll weigh that in.
  4. Review side-by-side options. We'll show Erie alongside other carriers when it makes sense.
  5. Pick a start date. Line it up with your current renewal so you don't double-pay or leave a gap.


If you'd rather talk in person, stop by either office. In Pennsylvania, we're at 108 E Grandview Ave, Zelienople, PA 16063, (724) 453-1122. In Ohio, you'll find us at 13823 Grant St, New Springfield, OH 44443, (330) 707-9055.

Written By

David Varrati

Owner, MVP Insurance


Owner, MVP Insurance

On this page

Common Questions About Local Erie Insurance

Is MVP Insurance part of Erie?No. MVP is an independent agency that works with Erie as one of several carriers. We can place Erie policies, and we can also quote other companies.


Can I get Erie insurance without an agent? Erie generally sells through local agents. Working with an independent agency like ours means you can compare Erie with other carriers too.


What is Erie Rate Lock?It's an auto feature that typically keeps your premium the same each year. Rates usually change only if you add or remove a driver, vehicle or primary residence.


Does Erie homeowners cover flood?Standard homeowners policies typically don't cover flood. We can add separate flood coverage through a partner like Franklin Flood.


What should I choose: limited or full tort in Pennsylvania?Full tort keeps your right to sue for pain and suffering after an accident, while limited tort restricts it in exchange for a lower premium. We'll walk through the tradeoff before you decide.


Will you check my Erie rate every year?Yes. We review your coverage at renewal and compare other options if your rate changes.


Choosing among local Pennsylvania Erie insurance agents really comes down to who will keep working for you after the policy starts. Erie brings strong claims satisfaction and financial stability. We bring the comparison, the local offices and the follow-through at renewal. If you'd like to see how Erie stacks up for your car, home or business, start your quotewith our team in Zelienople or New Springfield.


MVP Insurance is licensed in Ohio (license #37714) and Pennsylvania (license #519263), NPN 10588293.

MVP Insurance is a local, independent agency, licensed to serve individuals and businesses across Ohio and Pennsylvania.

We serve clients from our offices in New Springfield, Ohio and Zelienople, Pennsylvania and throughout Northeast Ohio and Western Pennsylvania, working with multiple carriers to help contractors, landlords and real estate investors, restaurants, retail shops, auto repair shops, professional offices and many other personal and commercial clients find coverage that fits.

Our Owners

Two friends who started an agency

Owner

Joshua Medure

I am a Penn State marketing graduate with more than ten years in insurance. My childhood friend David and I started MVP Insurance in Northeast Ohio because we wanted the people around us to have an agency that gives honest advice, real choices and someone who picks up the phone. I lead the agency’s insurance strategy, which means I read the policies so our clients do not have to. Away from the office, I coach youth football.

Connect on LinkedIn

About the Author

Joshua Medure

Owner, MVP Insurance


I am a Penn State marketing graduate with more than ten years in insurance. My childhood friend David and I started MVP Insurance in Northeast Ohio because we wanted the people around us to have an agency that gives honest advice, real choices and someone who picks up the phone. I lead the agency’s insurance strategy, which means I read the policies so our clients do not have to. Away from the office, I coach youth football.

Personal Insurance in Ohio & Pennsylvania

Coverage for your home, your car, and your family

Protect the everyday things that mean the most to you.

Homeowners Insurance

Your home is one of your most valuable assets. We compare carriers to protect the house, your belongings, and your liability.

Car Insurance

We proactively shop the market to find the best combination of coverage and price for every car in your driveway.

Renters Insurance

Own a condo or rent your home? We insure your unit, your belongings, and your personal liability at a fair rate.

Umbrella Insurance

Extra liability protection above your home and auto policies. Large coverage limits for a small added cost each year.

Life Insurance

Protect the people who rely on you most, so they can keep their home and lifestyle if the unexpected happens.

Flood Insurance

Standard home policies do not cover flooding. We help you add flood coverage through the NFIP or a private carrier before the water rises.

Business Insurance in Ohio & Pennsylvania

No matter how big or small your business, we protect it

Practical coverage for your people, your property, and the work you do.

Industries We Serve

Insurance built around the work you do

Every industry carries different risks. We know the coverage each one needs and shop the carriers that write it well.

Contractors Insurance

General contractors, remodelers, roofers, and trade crews. We cover the liability, tools, vehicles, and workers your jobs depend on.

Plumber Insurance

Water damage claims follow plumbers everywhere. We cover your liability, your tools, your van, and your crew, job after job.

Restaurant Insurance

Kitchens, bars, and cafes face fire, spoilage, and slip risks. We package property, liability, and liquor coverage in one plan.

5-Star Rated on Google

What our clients say

Our clients say it best. Here is what they share about working with Josh, Dave, and the MVP team.

Contractors & Tradesmen

General contractors, roofers, electricians and plumbers. We cover liability, tools, vehicles and crews so every job stays protected.

Explore More

Insurance Tips & News

Insurance tips for Ohio and Pennsylvania families and businesses

Practical ideas for protecting what matters to you.

How to File an Insurance Complaint in Pennsylvania: What the Insurance Department Handles, How to
24 October 2026
How to File an Insurance Complaint in Pennsylvania. What Pennsylvania households should know, explained in plain English by a local independent agent.
Pennsylvania Insurance Guaranty Association Explained: What Happens When an Insurer Fails, Claim
24 October 2026
Pennsylvania Insurance Guaranty Association Explained. What Pennsylvania homeowners should know, explained in plain English by a local independent agent.
Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Cancellation and Nonrenewal Rules: Notice Periods, Allowed Reasons Under
24 October 2026
Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Cancellation and Nonrenewal Rules. What Pennsylvania drivers should know, in plain English.

Insurance Questions, Answered

Questions our clients ask

A little clarity can make your next step easier.

  • What does an independent insurance agency do?

    An independent agency works with multiple insurance companies. We compare your options, explain the differences, and help you choose coverage that fits your needs.

  • Can MVP Insurance quote both my home and auto?

    Yes. We can compare home and auto insurance options together. We explain available discounts and check how the policies work together.

  • Do you insure businesses in Ohio and Pennsylvania?

    Yes. We help businesses in both states compare options for property, liability, employees, and commercial vehicles. The right policy depends on your work and the risks involved.

  • How do I import my current policy for a quote?

    Use our Canopy policy import link to share your current policy information. Our team can then review your existing coverage and compare options with you.

  • How do I report a claim or make a payment?

    Visit our Client Center for billing and claims information. You can also call either office for help finding the right carrier contact.

  • How often should I review my insurance?

    Review your coverage each year and after a major change, such as a move, new vehicle, or business expansion. Tell us what changed so we can help you check your protection.

Covington office, Monday through Friday

Call

614 E. Boston St., Covington, LA 70433

58418 Tyler Drive, Slidell, LA 70461

Request Your Free Quote

Let's make insurance simple for you

Tell us what you need. We will help you explore your options.

Call Pennsylvania